...and I decorated it with lots of stars

Feeling a little brokenhearted when I pulled this one together. There were some substitutions due to playlist.com not having all the songs I wanted and my laziness in refusing to upload them.

Original:
Lucero - Tell Me What It Takes
Joseph Arthur - In Ohio
Marc Cohn - Walking In Memphis
Natalie Merchant - My Skin
Neko Case - Knock Loud
Langhorne Slim - Lord
Dashboard Confessional - The Sharp Hint Of New Tears
Brand New - Me Vs. Maradona Vs. Elvis
The Drams - You & Me, MF
Glossary - The Reckless
Ingrid Michaelson - Keep Breathing
John Ralston - Haven't Missed You All My Life
Old Canes - Both Falling Bright
The Postal Service - The District Sleeps Alone
Taking Back Sunday - You're So Last Summer
Tegan & Sara - Relief Next To Me
Whiskeytown - Don't Be Sad
The Get Up Kids - Fall From Grace
Lucero - Nights Like These